The Stecci of the Bogomils

“And in the room in which I was sitting, there was a window, beyond it was eternity. And I was staring at the ground persistently.”

by Kalina Yankova

This epitaph from 1258 was discovered on one of the  stecci, unique Medieval http://www.wvwnews.net/story.php?id=3195 gravestones. There are at least three theories about the origin of these graves.

The most popular and striking of the legends is that the graves belonged to the Bogomils, a Christian sect which originated in http://www.wvwnews.net/story.php?id=1870 and Catholic Churches and penetrated as far as Western Europe.

One of the early defenders of this version is the Hungarian writer Janosh Asboth. In the 1880s he devised a whole system of explanations which connected the Bogomils to the unique reliefs on the gravestones. According to him, the floral motifs, the animals and the human figures imprinted on them depict religious scenes.

In recent years, however, moderately romantic historians are re-evaluating Bosnia’s history and question not only the theory about the Bogomilist essence of the Bosnian Christian church but also the connection between the Bogomils and the stecci.”During the late fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, when many of these stones were made, a significant part of the population of Bosnia proper was Catholic, and a large part of the population of Herzegovina was Orthodox…” British historian Noel Malcolm wrote in Bosnia: A Short History.

Contemporary historians seem to prefer a more prosaic explanation: namely that the language written on the stecci was a symbolic language that developed in the region. Some of the reliefs reflect barbaric scenes while others depict scenes from the lives of Slavic and Vlach nobility. Or, as Noel Malcolm sums it up, they may have the more trivial function of a most mundane decoration.

The epitaphs remain remarkable. A gravestone from 1094 reads: “You, who are honouring my stone, may have gone to the stars. And you came back because you found nothing there except, again, yourself.”

http://www.balkantravellers.com/en/read/article/204

From a Western Voices reader:

The Bogomils were a major heretical group that spread across Medieval Europe and in some places their faith and practice sparked civil war. In what is now southern France they were called the Cathars, and counted high ranking nobles among their followers. The Bogomil/Cathar heresy was descended from Gnostic beliefs, holding that all matter was evil. As a result, they rejected the eating of meat, and abjured marriage. Because marriage resulted in children (thus more “fleshly sin”), they were accused of homosexual behavior by their enemies, which is how the English word “bugger” (derived from “Bogomil”) for a perverse sex act or someone who practices that act, entered the English lexicon.

Bogomil/Cathar beliefs threatened the delicate social balance of the Middle Ages, and in the Languedoc Catholic forces launched a bloody Cathar Crusade (1209–1229) which eventually wiped the Cathars out, often indiscriminately. Simon de Montfort was a leader of the Crusade, who was killed by the Cathars. The famous Vietnam war saying, “Kill them all, let God sort them out,” originated with him. (More properly, “Kill them all, God will know his own”).

In the Balkans, as in Western Europe, Bogomilism attracted aristocratic support from nobles burdened by tithes and Church oversight. Some historians believe that today’s Bosniaks, white Muslims whose forebears converted to Islam under Ottoman occupation, are descended from families who had retained Bogomil sympathies. Similar sympathy for Islam from heretics was also seen in Spain, many of whose aristocratic families were followers of the http://www.wvwnews.net/story.php?id=2635" heresy, and who fought alongside the Muslim Moors who invaded Spain beginning in 711 AD.

As white people, the story of the Muslim Bosniaks, like that of the Albanians, is part of our collective history as a people.

2008-02-09